My Easter Admission on Gratitude, Grief, and Ambivalence — and How Faith Factors in Consoling Friends

No matter your religious beliefs or cultural point of view, I’ve always wanted this website to offer you ways to support your grieving friends. Some posts speak to specific topics of what to say (or not to say) when someone you know has suffered a loss. Others offer general insight into what is normal for one who is grieving. This one reaches into each of those areas.

First, I’d like to share this Easter- and grief-related post, Easter Admission: Gratitude, Grief, and Ambivalence, which I wrote for the Segullah literary blog.

For those not of my faith, please understand I’m not trying to impose my beliefs. Rather, I’m illustrating how — even for those with clear convictions — grieving can (and does) influence mourners long after the funeral, so long, in fact, that your friends might not seem like they “still” mourn. (More than seven years widowed, I no longer cry every day as I once did, but that doesn’t mean I don’t cry from time to time, even though my life has become full and fulfilling again.)                                                            EasterSunriseForSegullahByTeresaTLBruce-min

Grieving is a complicated business. For some, faith simplifies the process — but not always.

In the earliest days (and by days I mean weeks, months, and even years) after my husband died, my faith offered me an anchor to hold when the ground beneath my feet turned to unpredictable tidal waves. In the long nights when I could no longer sleep, I often turned to scripture for comfort, guidance, and connection as I read of others’ great trials and how well they did (or didn’t) cope as they relied on God for deliverance or endurance. It helped me.

But it seldom helped when others told me how or why or that my faith (or theirs) should, could, or would help me.

At first, I didn’t understand why I bristled at others’ attempts to console me by their declarations of faith and doctrine. After all, I’d lived my whole life by relying on prayer and study and devotion. Why, now that I leaned upon it even more, did I resent others’ telling me to do so? In time, I figured out a few reasons.

Why should you think twice before urging mourners to have more faith or speak to them in faith-based clichés?

  • I resented the implied message that if my faith were strong enough, my grief wouldn’t show up in ways that made those around me uncomfortable.
  • If I believed fully, their attempted consolations implied, I wouldn’t need to grieve. I’d “get over it” sooner. (Note: Never say or imply one who has lost a loved one should “already” get over it.
  • Those already feeling fragile in their faith may take your words as condemnation rather than support.
  • Never, ever tell a grieving child (or parent, or anyone, for that matter) that God needed the deceased loved one more than they did.
    • Do you really think the Almighty “needed” that individual more than the survivors needed their loved one?
    • Do you really have the authority to speak for God?
  • Never tell mourners that God — or the deceased — wouldn’t want them to be sad.
    • Grief is a natural, even healthy, response to losing ones we love.
    • Do you think the Almighty — or the one who died — would want loved ones kicking up their heels and saying, “Hooray!” about the death? (And if so, who authorized you as the spokesperson?)
    • Many Old Testament stories depict prophets and others openly mourning their own and others’ losses; one of the New Testament’s most poignant verses states simply, “Jesus wept.”
  • Never say, “She’s in a better place,” implying that all’s well because the loved one is now in heaven.
    • Even if the mourners believe this, it’s up to them to state it.
    • Sometimes grief and families’ lives behind closed doors is complicated. You might think the deceased was a saint, but the grieving family members might feel differently about their loved one’s eternal destination.

When and how is it appropriate to share faith-related comfort with mourners?

  • When they ask for it.
  • During discussions the bereaved initiate about faith and mourning.
  • Limit your professions to what gives you comfort. For instance:
    • RIGHT WAY: When my mother died, I found peace in reading from her Bible and studying the verses she’d outlined.
    • WRONG WAY: You should study your mom’s Bible and see what she marked in it.
    • RIGHT WAY: Sometimes, when I’m grieving, singing this hymn helps me feel better.
    • WRONG WAY: You should sing this hymn if you’re feeling sad. Or, I’m going to sing you this hymn right now to make you feel better too.

What’s most important to remember when comforting grieving friends?

Be there. Listen. Show up. Remember. Ask to hear stories about the one who died — using their name. Express your awareness of their loss.

7 thoughts on “My Easter Admission on Gratitude, Grief, and Ambivalence — and How Faith Factors in Consoling Friends

  1. Reblogged this on KyneWynn's Chronicles and commented:
    An insightful blog post about grieving and faith which resonates with me.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. […] via My Easter Admission on Gratitude, Grief, and Ambivalence — and How Faith Factors in Consoling Frie… […]

    Liked by 1 person

  3. My husband died 5 months ago from a neurological illness that was finally diagnosed three years ago. Today would have been his birthday and not one of our close friends nor his friends as well as my own family have made any contact with my son or I to ask how we are doing. This is very hurtful and it makes me feel that they do not care about his death or him – I guess the reality is that they are only thinking about themselves … I hope they do not experience this treatment should they ever lose their partner.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Teresa, I’m so sorry to learn of your husband’s recent passing and of the added pain you’ve felt on his birthday. Milestone dates like birthdays and anniversaries are already difficult when you’re grieving; they can feel even more agonizing when others seem not to remember or honor our loved ones on those dates. I hope your friends’ and family’s neglect to acknowledge the date stems from misguided hopes of not making you feel worse. (Among my friends and family, some later told me they stayed quiet on such dates because they didn’t want to remind me of my loss. They meant well but did not understand that raw, new grief is never forgotten. It’s always with mourners.) Some folks don’t understand the importance of speaking up to acknowledge such a devastating loss until they’ve walked a similar grief journey.

      Please be gentle with yourself as you adjust to this tremendous change in your life. You’ll be in my thoughts.


  4. How I wish my atheist brother-in-law had been more sensitive of my faith. Just five weeks after my beloved brother ended his life, I foolishly hosted a birthday party for my mother-in-law just as I do every year. My BIL, whom I hadn’t seen or heard from since my tragic loss, chose THAT DAY to try and dissuade me of my faith by saying there is no God, there are no miracles, Christians treat the earth and animals poorly, etc. His wife (my husband’s sister) was argumentative and enjoyed watching her husband’s cruelty. No hugs, no “I’m sorry for your loss”, nothing. It was absolutely the most malicious treatment I have ever received and what really takes the cake is they suffered a tragic loss of their teenage son decades ago and certainly should have known better. Unforgivable in my opinion and I never want to see them again.


    • Michelle, I’m so sorry your extended family treated you in that way. It was decent and kind of you to host a party for your mother-in-law so close to the time of your brother’s death while living through the raw pain of your own loss. I’m sorry. Faith or no faith, if they couldn’t bring themselves to say something to acknowledge your pain about your brother’s passing, I wish they had been able to simply put their arms around you and say thank you for this birthday party. Everyone grieves differently, and perhaps they still grieve their son in ways that come out inappropriately around others. Whatever their reasons, I’m sorry you experienced that. Please be kind to yourself as you grieve.


What are your thoughts on this topic?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.